The Spurs have been waiting a while for the Finals to start...will they come out rusty? Or will the extra rest give San Antonio's big 3 of Duncan, Parker, and Ginobili the energy to beat the Heat?

Monday, April 15, 2013

A Quick Reflection on the Flagrant Foul 1 Rule

The NCAA needs to get rid of the flagrant foul 1 rule.  During the tournament, we all wasted countless minutes waiting for the referees to finish reviewing potential flagrant foul 1 plays.  And we saw that an inadvertent elbow to the head could reverse a game’s momentum.  So, why keep this rule?  Basketball is a fast, physical game and inadvertent elbows to the chest and head are to almost be expected.  I understand that the NCAA is trying to prevent head injuries (with all the worry about concussions), but I think it is almost impossible to remove accidental elbows from the game.  In a typical scenario, where a defender is guarding very tightly, the best way to move the ball from side to side is to swing the ball over the top of the defender.  This move creates a little space and will keep the ball protected from any steal attempts.
The NCAA wants players to change their technique and swing the ball down around the shin level, but that leaves the ball in a vulnerable position.  Any player can swat the ball out of your hands when you put it low.  I was always taught to keep the ball above my head to keep it out of the reach of defenders…and based on my experience that was accurate advice.  With the ball above one’s head, defenders have a much harder time stealing the ball without being called for a foul.  The NCAA is crazy if they really think they are going to eliminate this basketball move from the game.
I think that the flagrant foul 1 rule should be trashed and that the outcome of inadvertent elbows to the head should be a stoppage of play and retained possession for the team that had the ball.

P.S. Really hoping Mitch McGary stays at Michigan with his buddies Stauskas, Robinson, and Albrecht…I thought it was pretty crazy that they all played AAU together…and then went on to help lead Michigan on a crazy and unexpected run through the tournament.

No comments:

Post a Comment